• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
Breakingviews  Holding Comic sues but the comic story’s on copyright law

Breakingviews Holding Comic sues but the comic story’s on copyright law

February 18, 2023
How To Break Into Top US Law Firms In 2022

How To Break Into Top US Law Firms In 2022

March 29, 2023
FL Family Law Statutes – What is It?

FL Family Law Statutes – What is It?

March 27, 2023
How to Investigate a Criminal Law Case 

How to Investigate a Criminal Law Case 

March 25, 2023
Cybersecurity Act of 2015

Cybersecurity Act of 2015

March 22, 2023
The Best International Law Schools In The World

The Best International Law Schools In The World

March 18, 2023
Are You Looking for the Best Practising Law Institute? Apply here

Are You Looking for the Best Practising Law Institute? Apply here

March 13, 2023
Copyright of Music Law in the European Union

Copyright of Music Law in the European Union

March 10, 2023
The Average Cost of Divorce

The Average Cost of Divorce

March 5, 2023
Spinal Cord Injury Lawyers – How Do They Help?

Spinal Cord Injury Lawyers – How Do They Help?

March 5, 2023
Answer our business law final exam quiz and improve your grade

Answer our business law final exam quiz and improve your grade

March 4, 2023
A Complete Understanding of Negligence and Liability Lawsuits 

A Complete Understanding of Negligence and Liability Lawsuits 

March 3, 2023
In which cases should you file a personal injury claim?

In which cases should you file a personal injury claim?

March 3, 2023
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use
Thursday, March 30, 2023
  • Login
Law Renca
  • Home
  • Law
    • Accident Law
    • Business Law
      • Copyright Law
      • Real Estate Law
    • Child Law
    • Women Law
    • Criminal law
    • Family law
    • International Law
      • Cyber law
      • Traffic law
  • Attorney
  • Divorce
  • Legal Advice
  • Contact Us
  • Pages
    • About Us
    • Cookie Policy
    • DMCA
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
No Result
View All Result
Law Renca
No Result
View All Result
Home Copyright Law

Breakingviews Holding Comic sues but the comic story’s on copyright law

by Penny Tucker
February 18, 2023
in Copyright Law
0

Did you pay attention to the one about the comedy writer who’s suing U.S. Talk-display host Conan O’Brien for allegedly stealing his jokes? It’s the state-of-the-art case of innovative kinds – from UK band Radiohead to software giant Oracle – the use of copyright protections to dam others from building on their smart but often spinoff ideas. Overly strict laws that stifle innovation aren’t any laughing be counted.

Freelance author Robert “Alex” Kaseberg contributed jokes to Jay Leno and different comics for years while, in February 2015, he heard O’Brien tell this one: “It turns out the Washington Monument is 10 inches shorter than formerly concept. You understand it has been a cold iciness when even a monument has shrinkage.” Pretty funny, the concept, earlier than knowing that he had published an almost equal crack on his weblog six hours in advance. After hearing a few more of what he believed had been his very own jokes finished through the late-night TV comedian, Kaseberg sued, looking for more than $six hundred,000 in lost income and different damages. O’Brien and his writers deny they stole the jokes, and tribulation is set for the subsequent month.

The case faces a few daunting barriers, maximum drastic tradition, and human nature. Celebrated comedians were “borrowing” jokes at the least, seeing that nineteenth-century vaudeville, with the only rule being that the borrower needed to add something to make the gag his own. And repeating an actual knee-slapper ranks excessive among lifestyles’ fundamental joys. Enlisting the law to forestall the exercise seems futile – as W. C. Fields may also have diagnosed while he allegedly paid $50 to have a joke thief’s legs broken.

Breakingviews Holding Comic sues but the comic story’s on copyright law 1

Yet the law is wealthy with tries to punish humor heists. Often the cases fail due to the fact the allegedly stolen cloth isn’t unique. That’s what came about in 1970. A choice dominated that copyright regulation didn’t forestall a filmmaker from using sure “stock” jokes advised by using comic and satirist Lenny Bruce. Other instances founder at the precept that copyright typically protects expression in place of underlying ideas. Hence the 1976 ruling that TV’s “Sesame Street” ought to present a skit that becomes based on another author’s tale, however, told in a very distinct manner. Sometimes, although, comic story-theft complaints prevail. In 1995, an employer argued that it could make T-shirts printed with comedian Jeff Foxworthy’s signature setup line, “You may be a redneck if …,” due to the fact Foxworthy’s punchlines were lifted from other comedians. The court rejected the argument, stressing that the form, now not the substance, of the jokes, changed into included.

The choice in Kaseberg’s case has already used similar analyses to disallow some of the writer’s claims. She tossed, for example, a funny story that began with the current information that the University of Alabama, Birmingham, had dropped its soccer software. Kaseberg’s massive end: “To which the Oakland Raiders stated: ‘Wait so that you can try this?’” Conan O’Brien’s version: “When they heard the news, New York Jets fanatics stated: ‘Wait, are you able to do that?’” The two punchlines, ruled the decide, have been distinct sufficient that permitting Kaseberg to claim possession of the joke “might fundamentally hinder, in preference to ‘promote the progress of the innovative arts.”

That conclusion should possibly observe the entire case – and it succinctly expresses what’s wrong with copyright in widespread. Creative kinds like Kaseberg deserve the law’s warranty that their labors gained’t cross for naught because of plagiarism. But degrees of difference among works that play on familiar terms or snapshots are frequently difficult to outline, and asking a courtroom to achieve these risks overbroad prohibitions discourage clean thoughts.

The song enterprise, as an example, continues to be grappling with the fallout from a 2015 infringement verdict of $5.3 million towards pop artists Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams, whose 2013 hit “Blurred Lines” become deemed too similar to the overdue Motown superstar Marvin Gaye’s “Got to Give it Up.” While the tunes share a fashion and maybe a bass line, many copyright experts say the melodies and rhythm truly range. In any occasion, the close to-file verdict may additionally have brought about different spats, like Radiohead’s 2018 project to singer Lana Del Rey over the similarities between her music “Get Free” and the band’s 1982 hit “Creep” – which in turn was accused of copying elements of the Hollies’ 1974 ditty, “The Air That I Breathe.”

Penny Tucker

Penny Tucker

I’m not the typical corporate attorney. Instead, I write about things I’m passionate about—including law, finance, and politics. In addition to writing, I’ve taught a class on writing for lawyers and am a contributing editor for lawrenca.com. To learn more, check out my site: https://lawrenca.com/

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • How To Break Into Top US Law Firms In 2022
  • FL Family Law Statutes – What is It?
  • How to Investigate a Criminal Law Case 
  • Cybersecurity Act of 2015
  • The Best International Law Schools In The World

Archives

  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • December 2021

Categories

  • Accident Law
  • Attorney
  • Business Law
  • Child Law
  • Copyright Law
  • Criminal law
  • Cyber law
  • Divorce
  • Family law
  • International Law
  • Law
  • Legal Advice
  • Real Estate Law
  • Traffic law
  • Women Law

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Law Renca

Copyright © 2023 Lawrence All Rights Reserved .

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • DMCA
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law
    • Accident Law
    • Business Law
      • Copyright Law
      • Real Estate Law
    • Child Law
    • Women Law
    • Criminal law
    • Family law
    • International Law
      • Cyber law
      • Traffic law
  • Attorney
  • Divorce
  • Legal Advice
  • Contact Us
  • Pages
    • About Us
    • Cookie Policy
    • DMCA
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 Lawrence All Rights Reserved .

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In