The Madras High Court today directed that an assembly be convened between law enforcement businesses and social media companies to talk about methods wherein they could cooperate to address online crimes.

Law enforcement agencies and representatives of social media/online companies – Google, Youtube, WhatsApp, Facebook, and Twitter – are expected to talk about the issue in an assembly chaired through the kingdom’s Chief Secretary.

During this assembly, the contributors are predicted to inspect such elements as what type of data can be made to be had by the agencies, what form of data must be made available to locate cybercrimes, the manner wherein help in such cases may be sought, etc. The meeting is to be held among May 20-27, and document on the equal is also expected to the submitted to the High Court.

The meantime order becomes passed these days by the Bench of Justices S Manikumar and Subramonium Prasad following submissions made through the social/online media corporations and the Government.


Senior Advocate Arvind Datar made submissions on behalf of WhatsApp; Senior Advocate PS Raman argued for Google and Youtube; Facebook changed into represented by means of Senior Advocate Satish Parasaran and Senior Advocate R Murari appeared for Twitter. Submissions for the state have been made with the aid of Additional Government Pleader, E Manoharan.

The order turned into surpassed in a 2018 PIL filed to link Aadhaar with email IDs and different online user money owed for simpler detection of online crimes. The Bench rejected the prayer for Aadhaar linkage at some point of the initial tiers of listening to. However, the Bench changed into induced to take a look at what measures were in location to counter such crime.

While responding to the Court’s queries, the Government knowledgeable the court docket that social media companies and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) have been frequently reluctant to share pertinent personal information to carry out research against cyber crimes. This had led the Court to implead the web organizations in the depend.

Submissions made through Social Media agencies

All appearing social media organizations have asserted that they had been cooperating with the investigating companies as some distance as possible, as and while suitable requests are being made for help within the investigation of cyber crimes. However, it changed into additionally argued that there had been positive limits to the assistance that could be provided by online agencies in such subjects.

Data talked about that in WhatsApp’s case, the content material shared among customers isn’t always available for the company to proportion attributable to its end-to-quit encryption policy. He argued, inter alia, that one of the reasons why the WhatsApp is popular is as it respects personal privacy. He additionally submitted that the enterprise is allowed to characteristic as such below Indian law. Further, he pointed out that steps had been being taken to minimize the abuse of the platform. It changed into additionally asserted that WhatsApp cooperates with government requests for help inside the investigation of cyber crimes. However, for it to provide records, the request needed to be made in a precise way.

A comparable difficulty becomes additionally highlighted with the aid of Raman, who appeared for Google and Youtube. He argued that Google in general response to requests made by means of the Government to proportion statistics to address cybercrime. However, for the organization to respond, the request ought to not only be made by means of a Government functionary, however, but it also needs to additionally come thru an authentic channel. Explaining the difficulty, it became talked about that during several instances, a public reliable could use his private email ID to are looking for help. Google might now not respond to such personal requests, he informed.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *